/- LeanCTX Formal Verification — Agent Handoff State Machine Formalizes the agent-to-agent handoff protocol as a state machine with proven transition safety properties. Based on LeanMachines methodology and VeriGuard offline verification pattern. Mirrors: rust/src/core/a2a_transport.rs, handoff_ledger.rs Reference: arXiv:2510.05156 (VeriGuard) -/ import LeanCtxProofs.Basic namespace LeanCtxProofs.Handoff.StateMachine /-- Handoff lifecycle states. -/ inductive HandoffState where | idle | preparing | signed | sent | received | accepted | rejected | completed | failed deriving DecidableEq, Repr /-- Events that drive state transitions. -/ inductive HandoffEvent where | prepare | sign | send | receive | accept | reject | complete | fail deriving DecidableEq, Repr /-- Transport content types. -/ inductive ContentType where | handoffBundle | contextPackage | a2aMessage | a2aTask deriving DecidableEq, Repr /-- Transport envelope validity requirements. -/ structure EnvelopeInvariants where hasValidSender : Bool payloadNonEmpty : Bool payloadWithinLimit : Bool formatVersionValid : Bool deriving DecidableEq, Repr /-- Check if an envelope satisfies all validity invariants. -/ def envelopeValid (inv : EnvelopeInvariants) : Bool := inv.hasValidSender && inv.payloadNonEmpty && inv.payloadWithinLimit && inv.formatVersionValid /-- The state transition function. Returns none for invalid transitions. -/ def transition (state : HandoffState) (event : HandoffEvent) : Option HandoffState := match state, event with | .idle, .prepare => some .preparing | .preparing, .sign => some .signed | .preparing, .fail => some .failed | .signed, .send => some .sent | .signed, .fail => some .failed | .sent, .receive => some .received | .sent, .fail => some .failed | .received, .accept => some .accepted | .received, .reject => some .rejected | .received, .fail => some .failed | .accepted, .complete => some .completed | .accepted, .fail => some .failed | _, _ => none /-- Predicate for terminal states. -/ def isTerminal (s : HandoffState) : Bool := match s with | .completed => true | .failed => true | .rejected => true | _ => false /-- Predicate for pre-send states. -/ def isPreSend (s : HandoffState) : Bool := match s with | .idle => true | .preparing => true | .signed => true | _ => false -- ============================================================================ -- Handoff State Machine Theorems -- ============================================================================ /-- **Theorem 1: Terminal states have no valid outgoing transitions.** -/ theorem terminal_is_sink (s : HandoffState) (e : HandoffEvent) (h : isTerminal s = true) : transition s e = none := by cases s <;> cases e <;> simp [isTerminal] at h <;> simp [transition] /-- **Theorem 2: The idle state can only transition to preparing.** -/ theorem idle_only_prepares (e : HandoffEvent) (h : (transition .idle e).isSome = true) : e = .prepare := by cases e <;> simp [transition] at * /-- **Theorem 3: Sending requires a signed state (cannot skip signing).** -/ theorem send_requires_signed (s : HandoffState) (h : (transition s .send).isSome = true) : s = .signed := by cases s <;> simp [transition] at * /-- **Theorem 4: Accepting requires received state. -/ theorem accept_requires_received (s : HandoffState) (h : (transition s .accept).isSome = true) : s = .received := by cases s <;> simp [transition] at * /-- **Theorem 5: Completion requires acceptance. -/ theorem complete_requires_accepted (s : HandoffState) (h : (transition s .complete).isSome = true) : s = .accepted := by cases s <;> simp [transition] at * /-- **Theorem 6: The failure event is always valid except from idle and terminal states. -/ theorem fail_from_active_states (s : HandoffState) (h_active : !isTerminal s = true) (h_not_idle : s ≠ .idle) : (transition s .fail).isSome = true := by cases s <;> simp [transition, isTerminal] at * <;> exact h_not_idle rfl /-- **Theorem 7: A valid transition sequence from idle to completed must pass through all intermediate states.** -/ theorem handoff_lifecycle_ordering : transition .idle .prepare = some .preparing ∧ transition .preparing .sign = some .signed ∧ transition .signed .send = some .sent ∧ transition .sent .receive = some .received ∧ transition .received .accept = some .accepted ∧ transition .accepted .complete = some .completed := by simp [transition] /-- **Theorem 8: Rejection is a terminal state.** -/ theorem rejected_is_terminal : isTerminal .rejected = true := by rfl /-- **Theorem 9: A signed envelope that fails validation returns to failed.** -/ theorem invalid_envelope_fails (_inv : EnvelopeInvariants) (_h_invalid : envelopeValid _inv = false) (s : HandoffState) (h_signed : s = .signed) : transition s .fail = some .failed := by rw [h_signed]; rfl /-- **Theorem 10: If envelope is valid and state is signed, send is possible.** -/ theorem valid_envelope_enables_send (_inv : EnvelopeInvariants) (_h_valid : envelopeValid _inv = true) (s : HandoffState) (h_signed : s = .signed) : (transition s .send).isSome = true := by rw [h_signed]; simp [transition] end LeanCtxProofs.Handoff.StateMachine