// Ensemble-uncertainty threshold tuning from recorded trajectories (iter 47). // // Iter 44 added CLAUDE_FLOW_ROUTER_ENSEMBLE_UNCERTAINTY_THRESHOLD — when // the unified KRR and bucket specialist disagree on the picked model's // quality by > threshold, the selector returns null so the caller falls // back to bandit. Iter 45 surfaced the disagreement value per decision. // Iter 46 persisted it to the trajectory JSONL. // // This iter analyzes the persisted distribution and recommends a threshold. // // METHOD // 1. Read trajectory JSONL. // 2. Filter to decision rows with ensemble_disagreement set. // 3. Compute distribution: count, mean, percentiles (p50, p75, p90, p95, p99), max. // 4. For each candidate threshold (default 0.05, 0.10, 0.15, 0.20, 0.30): // - Count how many decisions would have triggered fallback // - Compute the fallback rate % // 5. Recommend threshold based on three strategies: // - conservative: ≤ 5% fallback rate → only the tail extremes // - balanced: ≈ 10% fallback rate → matches p90 // - aggressive: ≈ 20% fallback rate → matches p80 // // USAGE // node scripts/tune-ensemble-threshold.mjs // node scripts/tune-ensemble-threshold.mjs --thresholds 0.05,0.1,0.2 // node scripts/tune-ensemble-threshold.mjs --since 7d --format json // // Exits 0 on success, 1 on I/O error. import { readFileSync, existsSync } from 'node:fs'; import { resolve } from 'node:path'; const ARGS = (() => { const a = { in: process.env.CLAUDE_FLOW_ROUTER_TRAJECTORY_PATH ?? resolve('.swarm', 'model-router-trajectories.jsonl'), thresholds: '0.025,0.05,0.10,0.15,0.20,0.25,0.30,0.40,0.50', since: null, format: 'table', }; for (let i = 2; i < process.argv.length; i++) { const v = process.argv[i]; if (v === '--in') a.in = process.argv[++i]; else if (v === '--thresholds') a.thresholds = process.argv[++i]; else if (v === '--since') a.since = process.argv[++i]; else if (v === '--format') a.format = process.argv[++i]; } return a; })(); function percentile(sorted, p) { if (sorted.length === 0) return 0; const idx = Math.min(sorted.length - 1, Math.floor((p / 100) * sorted.length)); return sorted[idx]; } function emit(payload) { if (ARGS.format === 'json') console.log(JSON.stringify(payload, null, 2)); else printTable(payload); } function printTable(p) { console.log(''); console.log(`Ensemble-threshold tuning — ADR-149 iter 47`); console.log('─'.repeat(72)); console.log(` Input: ${p.input}`); if (p.since) console.log(` Time window: since ${p.since}`); console.log(` Decisions with ensemble_disagreement: ${p.count}`); console.log(''); if (p.count === 0) { console.log(' No decisions in the trajectory carry ensemble_disagreement.'); console.log(' Iter 46 persistence wires this; pre-iter-46 trajectories will lack the field.'); console.log(' Generate fresh decisions with iter 16 bucket specialists loaded + a complexity bucket.'); console.log(''); return; } console.log(' Disagreement distribution:'); console.log(` mean: ${p.distribution.mean.toFixed(4)}`); console.log(` min: ${p.distribution.min.toFixed(4)}`); console.log(` p50: ${p.distribution.p50.toFixed(4)}`); console.log(` p75: ${p.distribution.p75.toFixed(4)}`); console.log(` p90: ${p.distribution.p90.toFixed(4)}`); console.log(` p95: ${p.distribution.p95.toFixed(4)}`); console.log(` p99: ${p.distribution.p99.toFixed(4)}`); console.log(` max: ${p.distribution.max.toFixed(4)}`); console.log(''); console.log(' Threshold → fallback rate sweep:'); console.log(' threshold wouldFallback fallbackRate'); for (const r of p.thresholdSweep) { console.log(` ${r.threshold.toFixed(3).padStart(9)} ${String(r.wouldFallback).padStart(13)} ${r.fallbackRatePct.toString().padStart(8)}%`); } console.log(''); console.log(' Recommendations:'); console.log(` Conservative (~5% fallback): threshold=${p.recommend.conservative.threshold.toFixed(3)} (~${p.recommend.conservative.fallbackRatePct}% of decisions)`); console.log(` Balanced (~10% fallback): threshold=${p.recommend.balanced.threshold.toFixed(3)} (~${p.recommend.balanced.fallbackRatePct}% of decisions)`); console.log(` Aggressive (~20% fallback): threshold=${p.recommend.aggressive.threshold.toFixed(3)} (~${p.recommend.aggressive.fallbackRatePct}% of decisions)`); console.log(''); console.log(' Set via: export CLAUDE_FLOW_ROUTER_ENSEMBLE_UNCERTAINTY_THRESHOLD='); console.log(''); } if (!existsSync(ARGS.in)) { emit({ error: `trajectory file not found at ${ARGS.in}`, input: ARGS.in }); process.exit(1); } const lines = readFileSync(ARGS.in, 'utf8').split('\n').filter(l => l.trim().length > 0); let cutoffMs = null; if (ARGS.since) { const m = ARGS.since.match(/^(\d+)([hdmw])$/); if (m) { const n = parseInt(m[1], 10); const unitMs = { m: 60_000, h: 3_600_000, d: 86_400_000, w: 7 * 86_400_000 }[m[2]] ?? 0; cutoffMs = Date.now() - n * unitMs; } } const disagreements = []; for (const l of lines) { try { const r = JSON.parse(l); if (cutoffMs !== null && Date.parse(r.ts) < cutoffMs) continue; if (r.type === 'decision' && typeof r.ensemble_disagreement === 'number') { disagreements.push(r.ensemble_disagreement); } } catch { /* skip malformed */ } } if (disagreements.length === 0) { emit({ input: ARGS.in, since: ARGS.since, count: 0 }); process.exit(0); } const sorted = [...disagreements].sort((a, b) => a - b); const sum = sorted.reduce((s, v) => s + v, 0); const distribution = { mean: sum / sorted.length, min: sorted[0], p50: percentile(sorted, 50), p75: percentile(sorted, 75), p90: percentile(sorted, 90), p95: percentile(sorted, 95), p99: percentile(sorted, 99), max: sorted[sorted.length - 1], }; const thresholds = ARGS.thresholds.split(',').map(s => parseFloat(s.trim())).filter(n => !isNaN(n) && n > 0).sort((a, b) => a - b); const thresholdSweep = thresholds.map(t => { const wouldFallback = sorted.filter(d => d > t).length; const fallbackRatePct = Math.round((wouldFallback / sorted.length) * 10000) / 100; return { threshold: t, wouldFallback, fallbackRatePct }; }); // Recommendations: pick the threshold whose fallback rate is closest to // the target (5%, 10%, 20%). If no candidate threshold gives the target // exactly, the closest one wins. function pickClosestTo(targetPct) { let best = thresholdSweep[0]; let bestGap = Math.abs(best.fallbackRatePct - targetPct); for (const t of thresholdSweep) { const gap = Math.abs(t.fallbackRatePct - targetPct); if (gap < bestGap) { best = t; bestGap = gap; } } return best; } const payload = { input: ARGS.in, since: ARGS.since, count: sorted.length, distribution, thresholdSweep, recommend: { conservative: pickClosestTo(5), balanced: pickClosestTo(10), aggressive: pickClosestTo(20), }, }; emit(payload);