davila7--claude-code-templates/cli-tool/components/loops/evaluation/devils-advocate-loop.md

name, description, category, interval, stop-condition, components, tags

name	description	category	interval	stop-condition	components	tags
devils-advocate-loop	Adversarially challenges a design or decision until every serious objection is resolved or explicitly accepted.	evaluation	15m	No unresolved serious objections remain — each is fixed or consciously accepted with rationale.	agent:expert-advisors/architect-review agent:expert-advisors/critical-thinking command:git-workflow/pr-review	evaluation design-review decision-making loop

Devil's-Advocate Loop

Loop Engineering — put a dedicated critic in the loop. It keeps attacking the design until the proposal survives scrutiny or is knowingly accepted with its trade-offs.

🎯 Goal

Stress-test a design, RFC, or architectural decision by generating the strongest possible objections, then resolving or explicitly accepting each one — no objection silently ignored.

⏱️ Schedule

Suggested interval: 15m (or run until the design is settled).

▶️ Run it

/loop 15m "Act as a devil's advocate against the current design. Raise the strongest objections (scaling, security, cost, edge cases, maintainability). For each, either fix the design or record an explicit accepted trade-off with rationale. Continue until no serious objection is unresolved."

🔁 Iteration steps

1. Perceive — read the current design/decision.
2. Reason — the critical-thinking agent generates the strongest counter-arguments.
3. Plan — for each objection, choose fix vs accept-with-rationale.
4. Act — update the design or the decision log; architect-review validates the revision.
5. Observe — re-run with /pr-review; stop only when nothing serious is unresolved.

🛑 Stopping condition

Every serious objection is either resolved or recorded as an explicit, justified trade-off.

🧩 Referenced components

• agent:expert-advisors/architect-review — validates each revision.
• agent:expert-advisors/critical-thinking — generates adversarial objections.
• command:git-workflow/pr-review — structured review of the design changes.

💡 Example

A proposed single-region database is challenged on availability; the loop either adds a replication plan or records "single-region accepted for MVP, revisit at scale" with reasoning.